Understanding Citric Acid: Its Role in Food and Health Concerns

Citric acid, a weak organic acid, is integral to the culinary and health sectors, primarily found in citrus fruits and utilized across various industries. Its discovery in 1784 by Carl Wilhelm Scheele through lemon juice crystallization marks its long-standing significance. With a staggering annual production surpassing 2 million tons, citric acid’s role extends from an essential food additive to a pivotal element in the Krebs cycle, highlighting its biochemical importance.

In the realm of food and beverages, citric acid is celebrated for its preservative qualities and its ability to balance pH levels, retain color, texture, and flavor, showcasing its versatility. Beyond its culinary applications, it finds use in cosmetics for skin brightening and in cleaning products for its effective antibacterial properties^[1]. This article aims to delve into the multifaceted world of citric acid, exploring its sources, manufacturing process, and its dual nature of offering health benefits while posing potential risks.

What Is Citric Acid?

Citric acid, identified chemically as C6H8O7, is a naturally occurring weak organic acid predominantly found in citrus fruits like lemons, limes, and oranges. It was first isolated from lemon juice by Carl Wilhelm Scheele in 1822 and is now primarily produced through microbial fermentation, using strains of the mold Aspergillus niger. This acid plays a crucial role in the food and beverage industry, serving as a flavor enhancer, preservative, and chelating agent, which helps in stabilizing and preserving food.

Key Properties and Functions

1. Flavoring Agent: Enhances natural fruit flavors and adds tartness to food and drinks.
   
   
2. Preservative: Extends shelf life by reducing pH and inhibiting microbial growth.
   
   
3. Chelating Agent: Binds with metals to reduce oxidation, particularly in fats and oils.

Citric acid is also a vital intermediate in the Krebs cycle, a fundamental biochemical pathway in cells for energy production. It forms various metallic salts and complexes, aiding in numerous industrial applications, including the removal of sulfur dioxide from flue gases. Despite its extensive use, the FDA categorizes manufactured citric acid (MCA) as generally recognized as safe (GRAS), though it notes that ingestion can lead to different inflammatory responses based on individual genetic predispositions. The average daily intake from foods and beverages is estimated between 0.5 to 3.5 grams per day ^[7].

Natural Sources of Citric Acid

Citric acid, a key component in many foods, acts as a preservative by inhibiting the growth of bacteria, mold, yeast, and fungus, thus extending the freshness of processed foods. Here, we explore the natural sources of citric acid, which are predominantly found in various fruits and vegetables.

Citrus Fruits

1. Lemons and Limes: These are the powerhouses of citric acid, containing up to 8% of their weight in this natural preservative.
   
   
2. Oranges, Clementines, Tangerines, and Grapefruit: Commonly consumed citrus fruits also have significant citric acid content.

Berries and Soft Fruits

1. Strawberries, Raspberries, and Cranberries: These fruits are not only delicious but also contain higher amounts of citric acid.
   
   
2. Gooseberries and Redcurrants: These lesser-known berries are also rich in citric acid.

Exotic and Stone Fruits

1. Pineapple and Tamarind: Exotic fruits that are enjoyed worldwide and contain notable amounts of citric acid.
   
   
2. Cherries, Peaches, and Apricots: These stone fruits have citric acid which contributes to their slightly tart flavor.

Vegetables and Other Fruits

1. Tomatoes: Both fresh and canned tomatoes, along with tomato-based products like juices and sauces, contain citric acid.
   
   
2. Cayenne Peppers and Jerusalem Artichokes: These vegetables contain citric acid, adding to their flavor profile ^[16].

This diverse list of fruits and vegetables highlights the widespread natural occurrence of citric acid, which is not only essential for food preservation but also enhances flavor and nutritional value.

Manufactured Citric Acid

Fermentation Process and Production

1. Fungus Utilization: Manufacturers use the fungus Aspergillus niger, or black mold, to create a synthetic form of citric acid known as manufactured citric acid (MCA).
   
   
2. Allergen Concerns: Aspergillus niger is a known allergen, and much of the citric acid used in commercial products is MCA derived from this fungus.
   
   
3. Production Scale: Approximately 99% of the world’s production of MCA is achieved through microbial processes using predominantly a mutant strain of Aspergillus niger.
   
   
4. Fermentation Details: The manufacturing process involves the fermentation of carbohydrates, typically from molasses or corn syrup, using Aspergillus niger. This process can take around 5-7 days, resulting in a liquid mixture containing citric acid and other byproducts.
   
   
5. Purification and Conversion: Post-fermentation, citric acid is separated from the mixture through filtration, crystallization, and centrifugation, then dried and converted into a powdered form for use in the food industry.

Safety and Regulatory Status

1. FDA Approval: Manufactured citric acid is generally recognized as safe (GRAS) by the FDA, though there are reports of sickness and allergic reactions to the additive, possibly due to mold residues from the manufacturing process.
   
   
2. Potential Health Risks: The ingestion of MCA may lead to harmful inflammatory responses in some people, particularly those with a genetic predisposition to a black mold allergy. The potential presence of impurities or fragments from the Aspergillus niger may trigger these effects.
   
   
3. Lack of Comprehensive Studies: Despite its widespread use, the safety of manufactured citric acid when ingested in substantial amounts and with chronic exposure has not been thoroughly studied ^[3].

Applications Beyond Food

1. Cosmetic and Personal Care Products: Citric acid is present in thousands of personal care products, including shampoos, conditioners, and moisturizers, where it helps adjust the acid/base balance.
   
   
2. Cleaning Products: Its efficacy in cleaning products is due to its ability to bind with metals and its antibacterial properties, making it a popular choice in household cleaners.

This section highlights the critical aspects of manufactured citric acid, from its production using Aspergillus niger to the safety considerations and its applications in various industries.

Uses of Citric Acid in Food and Beverages

Citric acid, a versatile and widely used additive, plays multiple roles in the food and beverage industry, enhancing both the quality and safety of products. Here, we explore its primary uses:

Flavor Enhancement and Preservation

1. Sour and Refreshing Taste: Citric acid adds a distinct sour and refreshing taste to foods and beverages, balancing sweetness and enhancing overall flavor profiles.
   
   
2. Preservative Properties: By inhibiting bacterial growth, citric acid extends the shelf life of numerous products, making it an essential component in food safety and longevity.
   
   
3. Stabilization in Dairy: In cheese production and other dairy processes, citric acid acts as a stabilizer, maintaining the desired consistency and preventing spoilage.
   
   
4. Antioxidant Function: It serves as an antioxidant in frozen foods, helping to maintain freshness and nutritional value.

Beverage Applications

1. Taste and pH Balance: In beverages, citric acid adjusts pH levels for optimal taste and microbial stability, enhancing the drink’s safety and flavor.
   
   
2. Flavor Profile Enhancement: It intensifies fruit-based flavors, making beverages more appealing while maintaining a clean, tart taste without altering color.
   
   
3. Versatility Across Beverage Types: Citric acid is used in a variety of beverages, including carbonated drinks, fruit juices, alcoholic beverages, and even coffee or tea, showcasing its adaptability ^[19].

Food Industry Applications

1. Color and Texture Retention: Citric acid helps retain the natural color, flavor, and texture of foods, crucial for appealing presentation and taste.
   
   
2. Enhanced Food Safety: It is particularly effective in home-canning processes, preventing foodborne botulism and other microbial risks, ensuring safety in food preservation.

Broad Utility

1. Preservative in Packaged Foods: Commonly found in jams, jellies, candies, and canned goods, citric acid prevents spoilage and maintains quality.
   
   
2. Pharmaceutical and Cleaning Uses: Beyond food, citric acid is utilized in medicines for stabilizing active ingredients and in cleaning products for its chelating and antibacterial properties.

This comprehensive utilization of citric acid not only highlights its importance in maintaining food quality and safety but also underscores its role in enhancing consumer experiences across various products.

Health Benefits and Potential Risks

Health Benefits of Citric Acid

1. Skin Care and Cosmetic Applications: Citric acid is widely used in skincare products to brighten skin, even out skin tone, and minimize fine lines by increasing the synthesis of glycosaminoglycans and thickening the skin.
   
   
2. Antibacterial and Antiviral Properties: It effectively kills bacteria and viruses, which cannot survive within its pH range of 3–6, and is used in cleaning products for its ability to remove tough stains.
   
   
3. Prevention of Viral Transmission: Citric acid helps prevent the spread of viruses like the human norovirus by binding to receptors where the virus typically attaches, offering a protective barrier.
   
   
4. Metabolic and Nutritional Benefits: It plays a crucial role in the citric acid cycle, enhancing nutrient absorption of minerals and protecting against kidney stones by making urine less favorable for stone formation.
   
   
5. Versatile Uses in Consumer Products: Beyond its roles in food preservation and skincare, citric acid is utilized in pharmaceuticals to stabilize active ingredients and in cleaning products for its chelating and antibacterial properties.

Potential Risks of Citric Acid

1. Dental Health Concerns: Both natural and synthetic forms of citric acid can harm dental health by damaging tooth enamel over time.
   
   
2. Skin Sensitivity and Irritation: When used in skin care, it can increase sensitivity to UVB radiation and may cause irritation; it is advised to use these products with care, especially in sunlight.
   
   
3. Allergic Reactions and Health Effects: Some individuals may experience severe side effects such as confusion, chest pain, or fatigue, particularly from high concentrations or improper use of citric acid.
   
   
4. Dietary Intolerance: People with intolerance to citric acid need to be cautious, as it is naturally present in many fruits and added to various packaged foods.
   
   
5. Environmental Considerations: Although citric acid biodegrades easily, its widespread use as a pesticide and in industrial applications necessitates consideration of environmental impacts ^[10].

By understanding these benefits and risks, consumers can make informed decisions about the products they use and consume, ensuring safety and maximizing the positive effects of citric acid in their daily lives.

The Bottom Line

Throughout this exploration of citric acid, its pivotal role across various domains—ranging from food preservation, health benefits, to industrial uses—has been unveiled. The journey from its natural occurrence in citrus fruits to its widespread application in food, beverages, and beyond exemplifies the versatility and essential nature of this compound. Notably, while citric acid enhances the sensory qualities of food and contributes significantly to metabolic processes, it is vital to acknowledge the balance between its benefits and potential risks, especially considering individual sensitivities and the impacts of manufactured citric acid.

Acknowledging citric acid’s dual nature—its indispensable advantages alongside the caution required in its application—encourages a more informed and nuanced approach to its consumption and use. The broad implications of citric acid’s function in food safety, nutritional benefits, and even environmental considerations highlight the necessity for ongoing research and dialogue. Ultimately, understanding the complexities of citric acid not only enriches our knowledge but also guides our choices towards healthier and more sustainable living.

FAQs

What is the function of citric acid in food items?

Citric acid serves multiple roles when added to food and beverages. It acts as a preservative, extending the shelf life of canned and jarred goods. It also prevents browning in fresh-cut fruits like apple slices. In addition, citric acid can be used to thicken products or impart a tart flavor to them.

How does citric acid affect the digestive system?

Although citric acid is present in acidic foods such as lemons, limes, and tomatoes, these foods actually have an alkalizing effect after they are digested. This means they become more alkaline post-digestion. It’s important to note that while acidic foods themselves don’t cause digestive issues like acid reflux or ulcers, they can exacerbate the symptoms in individuals suffering from conditions like heartburn, GERD, or acid reflux.

Can citric acid cause damage to certain materials?

Yes, citric acid can be harmful to specific materials. It can cause damage to marble, stone, and granite by reacting with the minerals in these materials, leading to potential corrosion over time. Additionally, while citric acid is generally safe for use on most metals, it can tarnish copper and brass.

What are the potential causes of elevated citric acid levels in the body?

High levels of citric acid in the body can be due to several factors. These include impaired metabolism caused by toxic metals such as fluoride, mercury, and arsenic; low levels of glutathione; or a diet high in citric acid.

source